Skip to content

The Theory of Floating Tiles

Let us think about the function that each of mahjong's 34 tile types has when held by itself.

1. Basic Tile Theory

The chance for any tile to become a pair or a triplet is the same for all 34 tile types.
However, when a pair turns into a triplet, honor tiles and edge-near number tiles are more favorable because they are easier to call.

But if we look at the ability to form sequences, tiles closer to the center are more favorable.
Honor tiles cannot form sequences at all. They can only become triplets.
If we assume a closed hand:

三万牌图四万牌图五万牌图六万牌图七万牌图二万牌图八万牌图一万牌图九万牌图honor tiles

That is how they can be ranked.
The illustration uses manzu, but of course the same is true for pinzu and souzu as well.
Keep in mind that tiles closer to the inside are worth more.

The value of honor tiles is simpler: tiles that can become valuable triplets are worth more.

Double wind tiles (double East, double South) > value honors > guest winds

Value honor tiles that can secure one han by calling are quite valuable, and are often more important than terminal tiles.
But once even one copy is discarded, their value drops sharply. If the second copy is visible, they become almost useless for attacking.

At that point, if you keep them, it is usually as a safe tile.

2. Interaction Between Tiles

Even when number tiles are isolated, combinations that are three apart are generally considered undesirable.

In particular, the combinations 1-4 and 6-9 make the 1 or 9 into a tile with almost no value.

一筒牌图四筒牌图 → the acceptance is 一筒牌图 through 六筒牌图
(after removing overlap, this is almost the same as the acceptance of 四筒牌图 alone)

六筒牌图九筒牌图 → the acceptance is 四筒牌图 through 九筒牌图
(after removing overlap, this is almost the same as the acceptance of 六筒牌图 alone)

In a 1-4 holding, the 1 is only really useful when you draw four specific tiles, such as 2356 or 2335, and expand it into two sets.

A pair of number tiles that are three apart is called a suji relation.
There is a rule that when you hold tiles in suji, one of the two tiles loses value.

The most obvious cases are 1-4 and 6-9.
But 2-5, 3-6, 4-7, and 5-8 also show the same negative effect in the kinds of tiles they accept.

That is because holding tiles in suji causes overlap in acceptance, and as a result the total number of useful tiles becomes smaller.

Hand Draws that can form a taatsu
二万牌图 一万牌图 三万牌图 四万牌图
五万牌图 三万牌图 四万牌图 六万牌图 七万牌图
二万牌图五万牌图 一万牌图 三万牌图 四万牌图 六万牌图 七万牌图
(Comparison) 二索牌图五万牌图 一索牌图 三索牌图 四索牌图 三万牌图 四万牌图 六万牌图 七万牌图

Once you look at the table, it becomes obvious.

In the case of 二万牌图五万牌图, the acceptance on 三万牌图 and 四万牌图 overlaps, so the combined result gives you fewer effective tiles.

If you hold 2-5, the acceptance on 1 only makes a penchan, so it is not very attractive.
You should understand a 2-5 holding as "keeping the 2 in order to make a ryanmen when you draw a 3."

That means when the 1 is thin, and when the 5 is a red five, the value of the 2 goes down.
The same applies to the 8 in a 5-8 holding.

As for 3-6 and 4-7, each tile is strong enough by itself that you do not need to worry much in the early hand about holding them in suji.
But in shapes like kuttsuki one-shanten, holding them in suji becomes a disadvantage.

Example
七万牌图一筒牌图二筒牌图三筒牌图四筒牌图七筒牌图五索牌图五索牌图七索牌图八索牌图九索牌图白牌图白牌图白牌图 Dora 三筒牌图

Cutting 七万牌图 here is a loss.
If you leave both 四筒牌图 and 七筒牌图, the negative effect of suji overlap appears.

If there are no other conditions, the correct answer in this example is to cut 七筒牌图.

Theory

Holding tiles in suji causes your effective tiles to overlap, so the end result is a smaller acceptance count. In particular, when you have **14**, the `1`, and when you have **69**, the `9`, function very poorly as set candidates, so they should be discarded early.

Finally, let us talk about combinations that are four apart.
There are five of them: 1-5, 2-6, 3-7, 4-8, and 5-9.

In the past, people tended to value these combinations because drawing the middle tile would create a ryan-kan shape.

Example
五筒牌图九筒牌图
Draw 七筒牌图 and it becomes a ryan-kan shape

But this way of thinking is meaningless, and even harmful.

Even without 九筒牌图, you would still accept 七筒牌图.

For example, if you compare 五筒牌图九索牌图 with 五筒牌图九筒牌图, the 5p-9p holding actually has one fewer accepting tile type.

If you cut 九筒牌图 from 五筒牌图九筒牌图, the only time that turns out to be a mistake is when you later draw 七筒牌图八筒牌图.
Outside of that, 九筒牌图 has no special meaning.

So even though combinations four apart sometimes do form a ryan-kan shape,
that does not mean they are inherently favorable.
The conclusion is that there is no need to care at all about preserving these supposed ryan-kan transitions.


Original Japanese page: http://beginners.biz/pairi/pairi03.html